and Where is the Danny Gokey this season? We need that fun personality and confidence from anyone...anyone?
Let's discuss:
- Siobhan Magnus - I still wanted her to tone it down more than she did. I want an emotionally raw performance without any yelling. For the first time I felt that she was really off key a bit, sometimes sharp. I felt bad for her as she was almost in tears at the end of the judging. I am sure this week will shake her up since she has always been praised. I liked how the cameras showed us more of the behind the scenes than we have ever seen before. It sorta showed the camaraderie (yes I had to look that up to spell it right) between the contestants.
- Casey James- I really like his confidence and the growl of his voice,, however, the constant smiling while singing is sorta irritating. Do you ever see Daughtry or David Cook smiling away while strumming the guitar?? No,,, ! He's gotta put some grit in his face to match the grit in his voice. Kinda get into the guitar a little bit,,, I don't know... just maybe work on really performing. I agree with Kara in that he does stay in the same range for most of his songs,,, the chorus was sorta repeat the whole time.
- Mike Lynche- He brought out the guitar again and sang a deep emotional song. I really liked it and generally Mike doesn't do it for me. It felt real to me and not 'cheesy' or silly. He connected to the song and had great vocal control. This was one of my favorites of the night. He felt like a true artist last night.
- Didi Benami- What happened to you?? She used to be one of my favorites and I just feel like she's sinking FAST. She is honestly on the verge of a nervous breakdown, and yes she is so reminiscent of Brooke White. The blonde hair, the tilted head smile when Ryan asks her a question, and the tears of emotional turmoil are just so similar. She was wearing a horrible sparkly evening gown, her hair was not happening, and I didn't feel the connection with the song. I sure hope to heck that she is able to pull it together and find better songs for next week, if she's still here.
- Tim Urban - Why oh Why are you here week after week?? Just GO AWAY! Stop voting for him people!! He sings with no conviction- so sick of his little eyes looking into the camera with his head tilted, the way he smiles honestly does urck me, it's so fake and put on, he will never EVER have a career in this business. I just want him GONE!
- Andrew Garcia- Guess who's back? Back again - Andrew's back! So, he finally lived up to the hype, 2 months later!! He took a good contemporary song- no oldies here- Forever by Chris Brown and made it super fun to listen to. He had swagger, confidence, and a smile on his face. It felt real and I really enjoyed listening to it.
- Katie Stevens- I still feel like she's just acting and over thinking every aspect of the performance. A true artist just makes us, the audience, feel like it is true and natural. She did have a great vocal performance, but the attitude and everything she tried to portray is so fake. She did need to pick a younger song.
- Lee Dewyze- He is finally performing like a star. His vocals were amazing and I really enjoyed the song arrangement. Lee does need to start owning it though, he has great chops, but it's just his personality and star quality that needs some polishing. One of my favorites of the night.
- Crystal Bowersox- So she has heals and can play the piano,,, hmm? Was it necessary? I don't think so, but I do like the change from the birkenstock's and flower dresses. Great song choice and I thought she did great. She'll be here for sure.
- Aaron Kelly - I thought to myself,, "Why tackle this infamous song?" since it was one of the shining moments from Kris Allen last year. Ain't no sunshine I think needs to be hung on the shelf and left alone. His vocals were alright, but there was no conviction on this song. Not my favorite from him. But he'll be safe.
- Lee Dewyze
- Andrew Garcia
- Mike Lynche
- Crystal Bowersox
- Casey James
- Katie Stevens
- Siobhan Magnus
- Aaron Kelly
- Tim Urban
- Didi Benami
4 comments:
janelle, i'm loving your idol forum, even if i dont' always comment. i almost COMPLETELY agree with every single think you said, except that I think Didi will go home and Tim Dorkman will stay cause he's got squeaky 13 year olds voting for him. Didi's tears and emotions are running to fast and high to keep he on. oh well, we shall see!
also, although i didn't LOVE Crystal's heels and piano playing, i think it was smart on her part to shake it up a bit other wise her flower power might have gotten a bit old too quickly, you know? she's still my fav and even though i didn't love what she did last night, she still made a smart move to do it!
katie, well, she along with too many other idol hopefulls just need to learn that no matter how good you are, you shouldn't sing whitney, aretha, or celine. you know what i mean?
Wow, you totally called the bottom three! I'm so sad that Didi went home. I really think they should have "saved" her. Now we're down to 6 guys and 3 girls. I'm really not a fan of Lee. I guess he has a cool voice, but I don't like his look or his personality. I'm liking Casey more and more, though, and I'm glad Andrew is back in the game.
Tim does need to go home. I actually kind of like him, but it's not fair to some of the people who are leaving before him. I guess he's the Sanjaya of this season. But I agree with Ellen that he's adorable. Just not for this level of the competition.
I definitely agree with your top two. They were awesome! I really don't like Tim or Aaron. They need to go!
My top ten is totally in line with yours! I am head over heels for Andrew! I have listened to his performance probably 22 times since Tuesday! OBSESSED! Thanks for the re-cap! xoxo
Post a Comment